Shadow Scale - Rachel Hartman

Shadow Scale by Rachel Hartman
My rating: 1 of 5 stars

Before reading this, I thought maybe all the low ratings were due to high expectations, and I lowered mine, telling myself that I didn't mind if Seraphina was traveling a lot - she would meet new people and learn new things. But that didn't help. I still found myself beginning to hate this book during the second half but didn't understand why.

I was still expecting a generally positive fantasy story with worthy characters, new and old friendships, knowledge gathered and used for good, self-discovery, and triumph against the bad dragons and the bad people who don't like half dragons.

What bothered me about this book was that all the good characters and relationships were systematically poisoned or stripped away. There was so much potential, but the whole story became centered around a character who had been abused as a child and is now determined to punish the entire world with their insidious, advanced powers. They're mentally and emotionally abusive in that mind-twisty way that makes you question your own sanity.

This manipulative character takes over the entire book, derails all plot points, and steals all hope. They are so powerful that no one else can achieve anything. It's both frustrating and disturbing. I hated that I was experiencing this. It was far too close to ugly reality for me. The constant tearing down and the very personal vindictiveness really weighed on me. It left a bad taste in my mouth.

At least the right people triumph in the end. But the ending isn't nearly good enough. There's still too much loss. What was this, YA grimdark fantasy in disguise?

Lord of the Fire Lands - Dave Duncan

Lord of the Fire Lands by Dave Duncan
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

The way this book began didn't do it any favors. It promised a different book, one in a similar vein to the first, where the King comes and claims a Blade, and then that Blade serves through danger and adventure, etc. This is not that story.

It wasn't long before events veered off, but once that familiar beginning built my expectations, it felt to me like the story was going off-course. For a long time, I couldn't figure out what the point of this long flashback was, and I was anxious to get back to the real story in the present.

It wasn't until about half way through that I accepted that this detour was the real story. Then I began to enjoy it, and now I think it's a better story than the one I expected. I'm glad I stuck it out and I'm looking forward to seeing the fallout for the series as a whole.

Update: It had been several years since I read The Gilded Chain, but several reviews compare the two endings, so I had to go back and remind myself how that one ended. Let's just say Duncan has no problems rewriting his own history! Now I'm even more curious about where he'll take it next.

Dissolution - C.J. Sansom

Dissolution by C.J. Sansom
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I've found that an essential part of mysteries for me is the characters. Can I care about them, like them, see them as having potential for growth? The mystery itself needs to be intriguing, of course, but a clever mystery feels empty to me without depth of character, especially of the main character.

So, how does Shardlake stack up? What we have here is one of the grumpier investigators I've read about. He loses his temper, snaps at people, becomes tired and overwhelmed, and makes errors of judgment. He's not a perfect man, but he's also idealistic and compassionate underneath that gruff exterior.

He has a core of insecurity because of a disability that he believes makes him less than worthy. He also has a wealth of spiritual and political turmoil to grapple with. As the representative of Oliver Cromwell during the dissolution of the monasteries, he has to wrestle with his sense of faith in a time of religious upheaval.

There's lots of room for Shardlake to grow in this series. I think it's worth continuing with the series to see if he finds his way. Oh, and the mystery held my attention too.