The Burning Stone - Kate Elliott

The Burning Stone by Kate Elliott
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This started out as a 5-star, couldn't put it down, book. It gave me just what I had been looking for in book 2. Then... well, sprawl set in. Plot threads multiplied, and complications began breeding. This is good. This is complex. But as the sprawl unfolded before me, I found myself wishing for a tighter focus on the characters that I care about.

All of the characters, even minor ones, are so well-drawn and nuanced, and they change realistically with events. I dislike so many of them, and the ones I like aren't perfect, but are subject to their own flaws as well as to drastically changing fates. It almost made me dizzy how quickly tides could turn. It makes me impatient to see where it's all going.

I do appreciate the textures of the world-building that all these characters bring, but I really just want more of Liath, Alain, Hanna and Rosvita (I love that old woman!). I don't care much for Ivar's story (I don't like him or his group of friends), or for the visions of the Eika chief (although I know it will be important at some point). There are so many tantalizing hints about important things, I am impatient to solve it all. But, it seems I will have to bide my time because this is going to take a while.

Since it was just a bit too slow in parts and spreading out a bit too much, it ended up not being that 5 star read after all. It's such a hardship to settle for 4, but it was still very good.

A Court of Thorns and Roses - Sarah J. Maas

A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that this is not YA. First of all, the heroine is 19. Second, it is lacking the cliches that I've come to dread when picking up a YA book - at least aside from the immature stupidity of the heroine, who insists on doing things she's been counseled / asked / told not to, seemingly oblivious to the danger. Also, the romance is quite adult, so let's at least go with New Adult if we have to label it anything.

This is an engrossing fairy tale retelling that turns into something much more. It's Beauty and the Beast, so the romance is predictable, but it's also about the Fae, whose world is beautiful, magical, wild and violent. The world and its conflicts are revealed at just the right pace to bring it alive. Then the ugly violence of the conflict overtakes the pleasant little romance with a brutality that I found a bit of a shock.

It's a solid start to a series that has me wanting to know more about the world and the Fae, both hopeful and afraid of what will happen to them.